MORTGAGE INSURANCE / WASHINGTON HOME LOANS
Mortgage insurance can be paid monthly, upfront, or through lender-paid pricing, and the tradeoff matters.
Compare lender-paid and borrower-paid private mortgage insurance using payment, rate, cash, cancellation, and expected ownership time.
The short answer: lender-paid PMI is usually reflected in the loan pricing
Private mortgage insurance protects the lender when a conventional borrower has a higher loan-to-value ratio. With borrower-paid mortgage insurance, the premium may be monthly, upfront, or a combination. With lender-paid mortgage insurance, the lender pays the premium and typically recovers the cost through a higher interest rate or other pricing.
Lender-paid does not mean free. CFPB's Homeowners Protection Act examination procedures state that lender-paid mortgage insurance usually results in a higher rate than borrower-paid coverage and generally ends only when the mortgage is refinanced, paid off, or otherwise terminated. Borrower-paid PMI can have cancellation and automatic-termination rights when legal requirements are met.
The better choice depends on the full loan, expected ownership period, available cash, tax considerations discussed with a qualified professional, and whether the borrower is likely to reach a cancellation point.
Find each cost on the disclosures
CFPB explains that monthly PMI appears in Projected Payments on page one of the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure. An upfront premium appears in the closing-cost sections. Lender-paid PMI may not appear as a separate monthly line because the cost is embedded in the pricing, so the borrower must compare the rate, APR, points, lender credits, payment, and total cost.
Request two Loan Estimates based on the same loan amount, down payment, property, occupancy, credit information, and lock period. A lower visible payment does not prove lower total cost if the rate is higher, and a lower rate does not prove the upfront premium is recovered during the expected ownership period.
Do not compare an unlocked quote with a locked Loan Estimate. Mortgage-insurance pricing and interest-rate pricing should be reviewed using the same date and assumptions.
Cancellation rights are a major difference
Borrower-paid PMI may be canceled at the borrower's request or terminated automatically when federal Homeowners Protection Act requirements are satisfied. The exact path depends on payment history, value, loan balance, investor rules, and other conditions. A separate article in this library explains those cancellation rules.
Lender-paid PMI is not removed from the rate when the property gains equity. The borrower generally must refinance, pay off, or otherwise terminate the mortgage to end that pricing structure. Refinancing has new qualification, appraisal, rate, fee, and break-even considerations and is never guaranteed.
A borrower expecting to make principal reductions or own the home long enough to request PMI cancellation should model that possibility. A borrower expecting to move or refinance sooner may reach a different result, but future rates and property values cannot be predicted.
Use a break-even comparison instead of a slogan
Ask the lender to show the payment difference, cash-to-close difference, rate difference, and cumulative cost at several reasonable ownership horizons. Use the same assumptions and label future appreciation or refinance scenarios as unknown rather than promised.
If an upfront borrower-paid option is offered, divide the added upfront cost by the monthly savings compared with the alternative to estimate a simple break-even period. That calculation does not include the time value of money, tax treatment, or opportunity cost, but it exposes whether the upfront charge is likely to be recovered.
The loan officer should provide the required lender-paid PMI disclosure when applicable and explain both benefits and disadvantages. A statement that one option is always better is not an adequate analysis.
A PMI comparison checklist
Mortgage-insurance structure is one reason two lenders can quote different payments on seemingly similar conventional loans. Transparent comparison turns that difference into a decision instead of a surprise.
- Request borrower-paid monthly, borrower-paid upfront, and lender-paid options that are actually available.
- Use the same loan amount, down payment, credit profile, lock period, and property.
- Compare rate, APR, points, credits, monthly payment, cash to close, and five-year cost.
- Ask whether the insurance is refundable and what cancellation rights apply.
- Model realistic ownership periods without assuming appreciation or a future refinance.
- Review tax questions with a qualified tax professional.
- Choose the structure that fits cash flow and expected duration, not the one with the least visible insurance line.
Numbers to request in writing
- Interest rate and APR for each PMI structure.
- Upfront premium, monthly premium, points, and lender credits.
- Total payment and cash to close.
- Estimated five-year cost on the Loan Estimate.
- Cancellation or termination path for each option.
Questions borrowers ask
Is lender-paid PMI free?
No. The lender pays the insurer, but the cost is usually reflected in a higher interest rate or other loan pricing.
Can lender-paid PMI be canceled when I reach enough equity?
It generally does not drop from the existing loan's rate. Ending it usually requires payoff, refinance, or another termination of the mortgage.
Official sources reviewed
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is private mortgage insurance? (reviewed )
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Homeowners Protection Act examination procedures (reviewed )
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is mortgage insurance and how does it work? (reviewed )
Program rules and borrower eligibility can change. Your loan team will confirm the requirements that apply to your scenario.
Turn this research into your Washington loan plan.
Share your timing and goal with Cory Williams first, or use the secure lender portal if you are ready for a full application.
Get my plan for this scenario Apply securely