Back to the mortgage blog

MORTGAGE INSURANCE / WASHINGTON HOME LOANS

Borrower-requested cancellation and automatic termination use different milestones, and FHA or VA coverage follows different rules.

By , Mortgage Loan Originator, NMLS #2864321 · One Real Mortgage Corp., NMLS #198414 · Published · 5 min read

Understand federal PMI cancellation milestones, documentation and common exceptions for a conventional mortgage on a Washington home.

First identify which mortgage insurance you have

Private mortgage insurance, usually called PMI, commonly applies to a conventional mortgage when the loan-to-value relationship or program requires coverage. It protects the lender or investor against part of a loss; it is not homeowner protection and does not make the borrower's payment optional. Removing PMI can reduce the monthly payment, but the route depends on the loan, payment history, property value and investor or servicer requirements.

Do not apply conventional PMI rules to every loan. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau states that FHA and VA loans have different requirements. FHA mortgage insurance premiums and the VA funding fee are governed by their own program rules, and a borrower should ask the servicer about the actual loan. Lender-paid mortgage insurance also works differently because its cost is built into the financing arrangement rather than billed as ordinary borrower-paid PMI.

Find the note, closing package, PMI disclosure and most recent statement. Confirm whether the loan is conventional, who services it and whether Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac owns it. A loan lookup or servicer response can help, but do not send personal information to an unverified website.

Federal law provides request and automatic-termination milestones

CFPB guidance says that for many covered mortgages on a single-family principal residence closed on or after July 29, 1999, a borrower may request PMI cancellation when the principal balance is scheduled to reach 80 percent of the home's original value. A borrower may also request cancellation earlier after additional principal payments reduce the balance to that level. The first request date should appear in the PMI disclosure.

A request is not the same as automatic cancellation. The servicer may require a written request, a good payment history, current payments, certification that no junior lien exists and evidence that the property value has not declined below its original value. CFPB explains that original value generally means the lower of the purchase price or appraisal at purchase; for a refinance, it generally means the appraisal value at refinancing.

Automatic termination generally occurs when the scheduled principal balance reaches 78 percent of original value and the borrower is current. Federal law also provides a final termination point at the midpoint of the amortization schedule for covered loans, subject to current-payment requirements. These rules have scope and exceptions, so the servicer should confirm the exact date and conditions.

Current value can create another path, but it is not automatic

Borrowers often ask whether appreciation or renovations allow earlier cancellation. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac servicing policies may permit cancellation based on current value under defined conditions that can include seasoning, payment history, loan-to-value thresholds and a valuation ordered or accepted through the servicer. Those investor rules can change and may be more favorable than the federal minimum, but a homeowner cannot establish eligibility with an online estimate alone.

Contact the servicer before ordering an appraisal. Ask whether the loan is eligible for a current-value review, what valuation method the servicer requires, who orders it, what it costs and whether substantial improvements affect the test. An appraisal purchased independently may not satisfy the servicer. Paying for the wrong valuation can waste money without advancing the request.

If the property has a home-equity loan or other junior lien, disclose it accurately. Do not transfer ownership, record a lien or make a large principal payment solely to trigger cancellation without confirming how the servicer calculates eligibility. A principal reduction does not necessarily change the scheduled date used for automatic termination, although it may support a borrower request.

Compare PMI removal with refinancing carefully

Removing PMI from an existing conventional loan may be less expensive than refinancing because it can preserve the current note and avoid a new set of closing costs. Refinancing creates a new mortgage, new underwriting and new pricing. It may still be worth evaluating when the borrower has broader goals, but eliminating mortgage insurance alone does not prove that a refinance saves money.

Compare the existing principal-and-interest payment, PMI amount, remaining term and servicer cancellation path with the proposed interest rate, annual percentage rate, closing costs, mortgage insurance and term of a new loan. Extending the payoff period can lower a monthly payment while increasing the time interest is paid. Cash taken out or costs added to the balance change the comparison again.

Use a break-even analysis that reflects costs and the expected time in the home, then review the official Loan Estimate. Cory's team can compare the file-specific options without promising approval or savings. Tax treatment is outside a mortgage comparison; ask a qualified tax professional about personal consequences.

A homeowner's PMI cancellation checklist

If a servicer denies a request, ask for the reason and applicable standard in writing. The CFPB accepts consumer complaints about mortgage servicing, but a complaint should describe the actual facts and include relevant correspondence.

  1. Confirm the loan type, servicer and mortgage-insurance arrangement.
  2. Locate the original PMI disclosure and identify the scheduled 80-percent and 78-percent dates.
  3. Ask the servicer for its written cancellation requirements and any investor-specific current-value option.
  4. Review payment history, junior liens and property-condition requirements.
  5. Use only the valuation process authorized by the servicer.
  6. Keep the written request, supporting records and the servicer's decision.

Do not confuse these three terms

  • Borrower-requested cancellation: you ask after meeting the applicable requirements.
  • Automatic termination: the servicer ends covered PMI at a statutory milestone if conditions are met.
  • Final termination: a backstop tied to the midpoint of the amortization schedule for covered loans.

Questions borrowers ask

Does PMI disappear when my online home value estimate rises?

No. A current-value cancellation path, when available, uses the servicer's rules and approved valuation process. Ask before ordering an appraisal.

Are FHA mortgage insurance and conventional PMI the same?

No. FHA mortgage insurance follows FHA program rules. Conventional PMI cancellation rights should not be assumed to apply to an FHA loan.

Official sources reviewed

Program rules and borrower eligibility can change. Your loan team will confirm the requirements that apply to your scenario.

Turn this research into your Washington loan plan.

Share your timing and goal with Cory Williams first, or use the secure lender portal if you are ready for a full application.

Get my plan for this scenario Apply securely